| 2048 | Minneapolis Millers | 106-56 | Erik Voldness |
| 2047 | Austin Bats | 98-64 | Trey Schalk |
| 2046 | Manchester Marauders | 102-60 | Sy Razi |
| 2045 | Minneapolis Millers | 105-57 | Erik Voldness |
| 2044 | Minneapolis Millers | 115-47 | Erik Voldness |
| 2043 | Minneapolis Millers | 108-54 | Erik Voldness |
| 2042 | Erie Seawolves | 88-74 | Doug Trojanowski |
| 2041 | Vancouver Canadians | 97-65 | Dan Courcelles |
| 2040 | Manchester Marauders | 93-69 | Sy Razi |
| 2039 | Erie Seawolves | 89-73 | Doug Trojanowski |
| 2038 | Vancouver Canadians | 115-47 | Dan Courcelles |
| 2037 | Erie Seawolves | 86-76 | Doug Trojanowski |
| 2036 | Minneapolis Millers | 107-55 | Erik Voldness |
| 2035 | Minneapolis Millers | 109-53 | Erik Voldness |
| 2034 | Austin Bats | 106-56 | Trey Schalk |
| 2033 | Fargo Nordiques | 99-63 | Andy Nemecek |
| 2032 | Austin Bats | 108-54 | Trey Schalk |
| 2031 | California Dreamers | 80-82 | Phil Doyle |
| 2030 | Philadelphia Liberty | 95-68 | Justin Zima |
| 2029 | Manchester Marauders | 107-55 | Sy Razi |
| 2028 | Nashville Outlaws | 91-71 | Scott Patterson |
| 2027 | Austin Bats | 94-68 | Trey Schalk |
| 2026 | Charlotte Knights | 97-65 | Matthew Wells |
| 2025 | Charlotte Knights | 87-75 | Matthew Wells |
| 2024 | Erie Seawolves | 84-78 | Doug Trojanowski |
| 2023 | Vancouver Canadians | 103-59 | Dan Courcelles |
| 2022 | Richardson City Blood Raven | 89-73 | Imran K |
| 2021 | Vancouver Canadians | 101-61 | Dan Courcelles |
| 2020 | Traverse City Beach Bums | 102-60 | Steve Meyers |
| 2019 | Richardson City Blood Raven | 89-73 | Imran K |
| 2018 | Richardson City Blood Raven | 96-66 | Imran K |
| 2017 | Vallejo Admirals | 95-67 | Noah Oppenheimer |
| 2016 | Vallejo Admirals | 65-55 | Noah Oppenheimer |
| 2015 | Austin Bats | 49-33 | Trey Schalk |
| 2014 | Daytona Cubs | 43-39 | Richie Ho |